The Lincoln Shield Cent, first introduced in 2010, replaced the Bicentennial designs that honored Abraham Lincoln’s 200th birthday.
While modern pennies may not seem valuable at first glance, certain Shield Cents from the 21st century have gained attention due to errors, limited mintages, and special features.
Some of these coins are worth hundreds or even thousands of dollars. Let’s explore 11 of the most valuable Lincoln Shield Cents you should watch for.
1. 2010 Satin Finish Shield Cent
The U.S. Mint released this special Satin Finish Lincoln Shield Cent in uncirculated coin sets. Unlike regular pennies, this version has a smooth, matte-like finish.
Because of its limited production, high-grade examples can sell for over $1,000.
2. 2010-D Shield Cent Doubled Die Obverse
This Denver-minted penny features a doubled die obverse, meaning some details, especially in the words “LIBERTY” and the date, appear slightly doubled.
This minting mistake makes the coin valuable, with some specimens selling for more than $700 in top condition.
3. 2011 Shield Cent Off-Center Strike
Off-center errors happen when a coin is struck while misaligned. Some 2011 Lincoln Shield Cents have extreme off-center strikes, with part of the design missing.
The most valuable examples, especially those still showing the date, can sell for over $500.
4. 2012 Shield Cent Reverse Die Clash
A die clash occurs when the stamping dies hit each other without a blank coin between them, leaving ghost-like marks. Some 2012 Shield Cents show impressions of Lincoln’s profile on the reverse side, making them worth $400 or more.
5. 2014-D Shield Cent Improperly Annealed Planchet
Planchets (coin blanks) that are overheated during minting can result in discoloration or unusual textures. A 2014-D Shield Cent with this rare error can be worth $600+, especially in high grade.
6. 2015 Shield Cent Broadstrike Error
A broadstrike error happens when a coin is struck without a retaining collar, causing it to spread out wider than usual. A 2015 Shield Cent with this mistake, especially if well-preserved, can be valued at $450 or more.
7. 2017-P Lincoln Shield Cent – First ‘P’ Mintmark
For the first and only time, the Philadelphia Mint added a ‘P’ mintmark on pennies in 2017, celebrating the mint’s 225th anniversary.
Though common, high-quality examples and error coins can be worth over $300.
8. 2019-W Reverse Proof Shield Cent
Released as part of a special West Point (W) Mint proof set, this coin features a reverse proof finish—with a mirror-like background and frosted details. These coins have quickly become valuable, reaching prices of $2,000+ in pristine condition.
9. 2020-D Shield Cent Struck Through Grease Error
A struck-through grease error occurs when grease or debris partially blocks the coin’s design. Some 2020-D Shield Cents with missing details, especially in the motto “IN GOD WE TRUST” or the date, can sell for over $250.
10. 2021 Shield Cent Die Crack Variety
Over time, dies develop cracks, causing raised lines or patterns on coins. Some 2021 Shield Cents show significant die cracks, particularly near the shield design and lettering. Collectors have paid over $350 for well-preserved examples with dramatic cracks.
11. 2022-D Lincoln Shield Cent Retained Struck-Through Error
In this rare error, a foreign object became embedded in the coin during striking and remained attached. A 2022-D Shield Cent with this error has sold for more than $500, making it a unique and valuable find.
Table: 11 Valuable Lincoln Shield Cents
| Coin | Mint | Value | Unique Feature |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2010 Satin Finish Shield Cent | N/A (Uncirculated Set) | $1,000+ | Special satin finish, low mintage |
| 2010-D Shield Cent Doubled Die Obverse | Denver (D) | $700+ | Doubling on “LIBERTY” and date |
| 2011 Shield Cent Off-Center Strike | Various | $500+ | Extreme off-center error |
| 2012 Shield Cent Reverse Die Clash | Various | $400+ | Ghost-like clash marks of Lincoln’s profile |
| 2014-D Shield Cent Improperly Annealed Planchet | Denver (D) | $600+ | Discolored or textured surface |
| 2015 Shield Cent Broadstrike Error | Various | $450+ | Struck without collar, expanded shape |
| 2017-P Lincoln Shield Cent | Philadelphia (P) | $300+ | First and only ‘P’ mintmark on a penny |
| 2019-W Reverse Proof Shield Cent | West Point (W) | $2,000+ | Unique reverse proof design |
| 2020-D Shield Cent Struck Through Grease | Denver (D) | $250+ | Missing design elements |
| 2021 Shield Cent Die Crack Variety | Various | $350+ | Visible die cracks forming patterns |
| 2022-D Shield Cent Retained Struck-Through Error | Denver (D) | $500+ | Foreign object embedded in coin |
Modern Lincoln Shield Cents may seem common, but rare varieties with minting errors and special finishes can be surprisingly valuable. Collectors now recognize these coins as hidden treasures, and their worth continues to grow.
If you check your spare change, uncirculated rolls, or mint sets, you might just find one of these rare cents. Whether you’re an experienced collector or just starting, keeping an eye out for these valuable pennies could be a rewarding hobby—or even a profitable investment!
