Jefferson nickels might seem like everyday coins, but some are worth much more than face value. These coins, named after Thomas Jefferson, have been around since 1938 and are full of history and surprises.
Whether due to minting errors, rare features, or impeccable condition, certain Jefferson nickels have become collector’s treasures. Let’s explore eight of the most valuable ones and their incredible stories.
1938-D Full Step Nickel
The 1938-D Jefferson nickel, minted in Denver, is a standout for collectors. Coins with the “Full Step” (FS) designation show complete and detailed steps on the Monticello design, making them rare.
One of these coins sold for an astonishing $33,600 in 2022 at an MS 68+ FS grade. Its detail and connection to Jefferson’s legacy make it a prized collectible.
1942 D/D Horizontal Nickel
This 1942 nickel is famous for its unique minting error—a horizontal “D” mint mark stamped over another “D.” Such errors are rare and exciting for collectors.
One of these coins, graded MS 64 FS, sold for $32,200 in 2006. Minting quirks like these highlight the artistry and occasional mistakes of early coin production.
1940 Reverse of 1938 Proof Nickel
The 1940 Jefferson nickel features a reverse design from 1938, blending two years into one coin. This proof coin, with a pristine PR 68 grade, sold for $28,750 in 2011.
Its unique design and historical connection make it a fascinating piece for collectors.
1953-S Full Step Nickel
The 1953-S nickel, minted in San Francisco, reached $24,000 in 2019 at an MS 65 FS grade.
The detailed steps on Monticello are a standout feature, earning it the coveted Full Step designation. Coins like this represent Jefferson’s enduring influence on American history.
1939 Doubled Monticello Nickel
A minting error gives the 1939 Doubled Monticello nickel its value. This error caused the design to appear doubled, creating a striking visual effect.
A coin in MS 67 FS condition sold for $23,500 in 2019. Its rarity and unique look make it a collector’s favorite.
Collectible Insights
Jefferson nickels capture moments in American history, from wartime changes in coin materials to intricate designs that reflect Jefferson’s ideals.
Each coin tells a story—whether through minting errors, rare details, or its connection to pivotal historical events.
These coins show that value isn’t just about money—it’s about preserving pieces of history. If you’re lucky enough to find one of these rare nickels, you’re not just holding a coin; you’re holding a slice of American heritage.
