A 1943 Penny Sold for $840,000—Could You Have One?

By Amit Bansal

Published on:

A 1943 Penny Sold for $840,000

Coin collecting is an exciting hobby that combines history, art, and the thrill of discovering rare and valuable coins. While most coins are worth only their face value, some stand out due to minting errors, rarity, or special features.

This article explores the 1950 Jefferson Nickel, which is valued at $50, and four other rare coins, some of which have sold for six-figure sums at auctions.

1950 Jefferson Nickel – A Collector’s Favorite

The 1950 Jefferson Nickel is a well-known coin in the numismatic world. Certain varieties of this coin are especially valuable, particularly the 1950-D (Denver Mint) version.

Key Features:

  • Mint Mark Variations: Struck at the Philadelphia (no mint mark), Denver (D), and San Francisco (S) mints. The Denver variety is the rarest.
  • Full Steps (FS) Designation: Coins with a clearly visible Monticello staircase on the reverse are worth more.

Value:

A 1950-D Jefferson Nickel with Full Steps (FS) can sell for $50 or more, depending on its condition.

1949-D/S Jefferson Nickel – A Unique Overstrike Error

This coin is a rare error from the Denver Mint, where the “D” mint mark was stamped over an existing San Francisco (S) mint mark.

Key Features:

  • Overstruck Mint Mark: The “D/S” marking makes it a standout error coin.
  • High Demand: Collectors prize this coin for its rarity and minting mistake.

Value:

A 1949-D/S Jefferson Nickel can be worth $60 or more, depending on its grade.

1943-D Bronze Lincoln Cent – A Six-Figure Rarity

During World War II, pennies were made of steel instead of copper to save materials. However, some leftover bronze planchets from 1942 were accidentally used, creating one of the rarest U.S. coins.

Key Features:

  • Minting Error: Struck in bronze instead of steel, making it highly collectible.
  • Historical Significance: A wartime mistake from the Denver Mint.

Value:

This coin is extremely rare and has sold for up to $840,000 at auction.

1943-S Bronze Lincoln Cent – Another Wartime Error

Similar to the 1943-D version, the 1943-S Bronze Lincoln Cent was mistakenly struck on a bronze planchet instead of the steel used that year.

Key Features:

  • Limited Mintage: Only a few of these coins exist today.
  • Minting Mistake: Created by accident at the San Francisco Mint.

Value:

This rare penny has sold for around $504,000 at auction.

1944-S Steel Lincoln Cent – A Leftover Planchet Mistake

By 1944, the U.S. Mint switched back to using copper for pennies. However, a few leftover steel planchets from 1943 were mistakenly used, making the 1944-S Steel Lincoln Cent one of the rarest pennies ever.

Key Features:

  • Unintended Steel Composition: Most 1944 pennies were copper, but this one was mistakenly made of steel.
  • Only Two Known Examples: This extreme rarity makes it highly valuable.

Value:

With only two known examples, this coin has an estimated value of $373,750 or more.

Summary of Valuable Coins

Coin TypeMint MarkKey FeatureEstimated Value
1950 Jefferson NickelDFull Steps (FS) Designation$50+
1949-D/S Jefferson NickelD/SOverstruck Mint Mark$60+
1943-D Bronze Lincoln CentDBronze Planchet ErrorUp to $840,000
1943-S Bronze Lincoln CentSBronze Planchet ErrorAround $504,000
1944-S Steel Lincoln CentSSteel Planchet Error$373,750+

What Makes These Coins Valuable?

Several factors determine why these coins are worth so much:

  • Minting Errors: Coins with mistakes, such as overstrikes or incorrect metals, are highly sought after.
  • Rarity: The fewer coins available, the higher the demand and value.
  • Condition: Coins in better shape (higher grades) sell for more money.
  • Historical Significance: Wartime minting changes and unique stories add to a coin’s appeal.

For collectors, these rare coins are more than just money—they’re a piece of history that tells the story of U.S. coinage. Finding one of these valuable coins in your collection could mean a big payday, making coin collecting both fun and rewarding.

Amit Bansal

Amit is a writer and consultant in Social Security and financial aid, dedicated to simplifying college funding. His work focuses on debt reduction and maximizing educational access for students from all backgrounds.

Recommend For You

Leave a Comment