Morgan and Peace Dollars: What Makes These Coins So Valuable?

By Amit Bansal

Published on:

What Makes These Coins So Valuable

Silver dollars are more than just old coins. They’re a piece of history, a potential investment, and sometimes even a family heirloom.

Whether you’ve inherited one, found one at a flea market, or are looking to start a collection, it’s important to know their value and how to care for them properly.

Let’s break it down in a way that’s easy to understand.

How to Determine the Value of a Silver Dollar

Several factors affect the value of silver dollars. Here’s what to keep in mind:

1. Metal Content

Most U.S. silver dollars minted before 1935 are 90% silver and 10% copper. Their value depends partly on the current market price of silver, which fluctuates over time.

2. Rarity

Coins made in smaller numbers or at specific mints, like Carson City (CC), are much harder to find. These rare coins are highly prized by collectors.

3. Condition

A coin’s condition—or grade—makes a big difference in its value. Grades range from Poor (P-1) to Mint State (MS-70). Coins with little wear, sharp details, and no scratches are worth much more.

4. Collector Demand

Some coins are valuable because of their history, unique designs, or minting errors. If collectors are after a specific type, demand can push prices higher.

Types of Silver Dollars

Here are two of the most well-known silver dollar types:

Morgan Dollar (1878–1921)

These are famous for their detailed designs and are especially valuable if they were minted in places like Carson City.

Peace Dollar (1921–1935)

Created to celebrate peace after World War I, these coins feature a striking image of Lady Liberty and are also popular among collectors.

How to Evaluate a Silver Dollar

To figure out what your silver dollar is worth, follow these steps:

  1. Identify the Type: Check if it’s a Morgan, Peace, or another variety.
  2. Find the Mintmark: Look for a small letter near the bottom of the coin’s reverse side. Marks like “CC,” “S,” or “D” tell you where it was made.
  3. Check the Condition: Inspect for wear, scratches, or damage. Coins in better condition are worth more.
  4. Assess the Silver Content: Even worn coins hold value based on their silver content.

What Should You Do With Your Silver Dollars?

Silver dollars can be worth more than you think. Here are a few options for what to do with them:

Keep Them

Many people hold onto silver dollars because of their historical and sentimental value.

Sell Them

If you’re looking to sell, consider:

  • Coin Dealers: Trusted experts who can appraise and buy coins.
  • Auctions: A great option for rare or valuable coins.
  • Online Marketplaces: Sites like eBay or Heritage Auctions let you reach a global audience.

Pass Them Down

Silver dollars make meaningful heirlooms. They combine value with a personal connection to the past.

Tips for Preserving Your Silver Dollars

To keep your coins in top shape:

  • Handle With Care: Always hold coins by their edges to avoid leaving fingerprints.
  • Store Safely: Use coin albums, airtight containers, or protective holders to prevent damage.
  • Avoid Cleaning: Cleaning can reduce a coin’s value by removing its natural patina.
  • Get Professional Grading: Services like PCGS or NGC can certify a coin’s value and condition, making it more appealing to buyers.

Why Silver Dollars Are Special

Silver dollars aren’t just old coins. They tell stories about America’s history and can connect us to the past.

Whether you’re a collector, investor, or someone who’s just curious, taking the time to learn about these coins can pay off—literally and figuratively.

Amit Bansal

Amit is a writer and consultant in Social Security and financial aid, dedicated to simplifying college funding. His work focuses on debt reduction and maximizing educational access for students from all backgrounds.

Recommend For You

Leave a Comment